It is likely that the non-defaulting parties can show a legitimate interest in the enforcement of the primary obligation of a party to pay its share of costs. Liam O'Flynn Deputy Head of Design at Eirtech Aviation Services Ltd. Ireland. Applying the Cavendish principles, it was held that the claimant’s obligation to pay the higher rent in the lease was a secondary obligation, engaged once the primary obligation in the side letter to pay the lower rent had been breached. Please click Confirm below to continue. Dentons is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates. This website and its publications are not designed to provide legal or other advice and you should not take, or refrain from taking, action based on its content. You will now be taken from the global Dentons website to the $redirectingsite website. Different cases have taken different approaches to which obligations they characterise as primary and secondary. One way to mitigate the risk of a take or pay clause being held to be penal would be to draft the provisions in a way that offsets the potentially harsh effects of the provisions on the buyer (i.e. Liam has 6 jobs listed on their profile. The Dentons US Public Policy Team is pleased to release its annual Policy Scan, our comprehensive overview of the policy and political landscape in 2020. The Dentons team also included associates Torquil Law, Michael Walton, Liam O'Flynn and Wei Wu. However, the court held that the fact the loss resulting from that breach may vary in amount depending on the circumstances at the time does not of itself give rise to any inference that the sum agreed to be paid is a penalty, provided that it is not extravagant and unconscionable. Liam O'Flynn. In the context of companies operating in the oil and gas sector, one potential major issue relates to the delivery of hydrocarbons under "take or pay" or "send or pay" regimes; companies that have committed to delivering or receiving hydrocarbons may find themselves unable to meet the required contractual values as a result of the pandemic and/or reduced demand, and may be paying liquidated damages (LDs) instead. The Legal 500 EMEA 2019 recognizes over 130 Dentons lawyers. Liam is an associate in the Energy, Transport and Infrastructure practice, working on a wide range of energy matters, including UK and international M&A, regulatory and projects work in the oil and gas, power, and renewable industries. Liam O’Flynn Dentons. Liam O'Flynn Managing Director, Advisory at KPMG. Unsolicited emails and other information sent to Dentons will not be considered confidential, may be disclosed to others, may not receive a response, and do not create a lawyer-client relationship. In the current climate, the only certainty is that we live in uncertain times. Such mitigation mechanisms could include the common "make-up" rights for the buyer, where the buyer can reclaim the gas for which it paid at a later date or the "take or pay" price being set at a discount to the prevailing contract price. Liam O’Flynn (LF) Dentons Rebecca Anderson (RA) Dentons Richard Pomroy (RP) Wales & West Utilities ... Update: CWa explained that Dentons had previously created a suite of documents with the changed and updated Legal Text, so this action could now be closed. University of Law (Moorgate), +3 more. Dentons, +6 more. Native American Law and Policy (United States), Pensions, Benefits and Executive Compensation, Venture Technology and Emerging Growth Companies, White Collar and Government Investigations, Vivienne Westwood Limited v. Conduit Street Development Limited. What is the nature and extent of the legitimate interest of the innocent party in having the primary obligation performed? For example, the case of Vivienne Westwood Limited v. Conduit Street Development Limited[2017] EWHC 350 (Ch) involved a lease and a side letter between the claimant and the defendant for a clothing and fashion store. Liam O'Flynn. This website and its publications are not designed to provide legal or other advice and you should not take, or refrain from taking, action based on its content. All rights reserved. Attorney Advertising. New York City Metropolitan Area. O'FLYNN, (Co. Kildare) - March 14, 2018, (very peacefully), at the Mater Private Hospital, Liam, beloved husband of Jane; Sadly missed by his loving wife, sister, brothers-in-law, sisters-in-law, nieces, nephews, relatives and his many friends. Liam O'Flynn Senior IT Project Manager. Extension fees in the Extension Agreements, by which Holyoake agreed to pay a fee for the right to an extension of time to pay and, if he made repayment by a certain date, would be credited against his overall debt, were held to be primary obligations, because they were simply the price that Holyoake paid for the right to pay later. Liam O'Flynn. The English courts will not interfere in the parties' primary obligations, which are a matter for negotiation. To proceed, please click Accept. The effect of the side letter was that, notwithstanding the terms of the lease, the defendant agreed to accept yearly rent at a lower rate. In this article, we recap the latest position on penalties under English law, looking in particular at LDs, take or pay arrangements and forfeiture issues related to the law on penalties.1. Liam O'Flynn Senior IT Project Manager. Working with Dentons, you will have the opportunity to learn from the best lawyers in the industry at the largest law firm in the world. But as you navigate the unknown, Dentons will be there to support you in this New Dynamic. Liam O'Flynn Associate at Dentons. contractual terms that are not enforceable in the English courts because of their penal character) was somewhat unclear. Dentons is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates. Dentons launches combination with leading law firm in Angola. Start by clicking here, Dentons achieves top rankings in Legal 500 Asia Pacific 2020. Closed. Liam O'Flynn Associate at Dentons London. Liam O'Flynn. London, United Kingdom. As a starting point, the courts have followed the approach reaffirmed in Cavendish, where it is first determined whether the obligation in question is primary or secondary. Liam O'Flynn Senior IT Project Manager. In the case of ZCCM Investments Holdings plc v. Konkola Copper Mines plc [2017] EWHC 3288 (Comm), by contrast the court held that there was nothing extravagant, exorbitant or unconscionable in requiring a commercial party under the acceleration clause in a settlement agreement to pay immediately the full amount of the loan in the event of any non-compliance with its terms. A redemption charge on early repayment was not a penalty, even though it required Holyoake to repay the entire £12 million plus two years' interest if he made early repayment at any stage, because it did not arise upon a breach of contract but rather upon Holyoake exercising a right to repay early. Liam O'Flynn. Liam O'Flynn. There have been a number of cases in recent years that have bolstered and confirmed the Cavendish test. Dentons | 97,546 followers on LinkedIn. As with take or pay clauses, there has to date been no English law case that has addressed such forfeiture provisions. London. The first was a provision that would involve the seller giving up its right to future payments. Cookie Consent Manager © 2020 Dentons. For example, in GPP Big Field and other v. Solar EPC Solutions [2018] EWHC 2866 (Comm), the references to "penalty" in the clause were only held to be "equivocal indications"; it was the substance of the clause that was relevant (and the provisions were held by the court not to be penalties). Dentons becomes the first global law firm in Utah, and continues the momentum of Project Golden Spike, helping clients navigate the New Dynamic in 36 US locations. The 2019 edition of The Legal 500 Europe, Middle East and Africa has recognized 133 Dentons lawyers, of which 89 have been included in the elite “Leading Lawyers” list, while 44 are listed as “Next Generation Lawyers”. View Liam O'Flynn’s profile on LinkedIn, the world’s largest professional community. David Tennant, Adam Brown and Liam O’Flynn Dentons UK and Middle East LLP Albania 7 Alban Caushi CR Partners Angola 12 Emanuela Vunge and Mafalda Francisco Matos LEAD Advogados – Sociedade de Advogados RL Austria 19 Thomas Starlinger Schima Mayer Starlinger Rechtsanwälte GmbH Brazil 25 Giovani Loss and Felipe Feres Liam O'Flynn Associate at Dentons. requiring the buyer to pay full price for gas that it is not actually taking and that the seller could potentially dispose of elsewhere). However, applying the Cavendish test, the following tentative conclusions can be drawn: Cookie Consent Manager © 2020 Dentons. As the COVID-19 global pandemic continues to interrupt the way companies do business and has a significant impact on profitability, companies are looking at and re-examining their existing contractual arrangements to understand what relationships will survive the pandemic, and which ones may need to be reassessed. The starting point for any court will therefore be that there is a strong presumption that it should not interfere in the terms of their contract. Liam O'Flynn Senior IT Project Manager. In 2020, Dentons has announced 23 new offices. Cavendish clarified the test in relation to penalties and altered the test from the former "genuine pre-estimate of loss" to the following: Notably, in Cavendish the majority of the Supreme Court held the two relevant provisions to be primary, not secondary, obligations, and therefore the penalties doctrine did not apply: Cavendish also made reference (obiter and in passing) to "take or pay" provisions in oil and gas contracts, referring to them as "contingent primary obligations", as opposed to secondary obligations concerning damages for breach. The transaction was led by partner Danielle Beggs and associate Michael Walton with assistance from associate Liam O'Flynn in London and Energy Regulatory partner Leila Hubeaut and associate Ergen Ege from Dentons' Paris office. Dentons does not accept any liability for its use. Similarly, in GPP, the court held that the delay damages did not exceed a genuine attempt to estimate in advance the loss which the first claimant would be likely to suffer from a breach, and that that sum was not in any way extravagant or unconscionable in comparison with the legitimate interest of the first claimant in ensuring timely performance. Liam O'Flynn was an Irish uilleann piper and Irish traditional musician. Further, the sum was payable only on a single type of breach – failure to achieve commissioning of the plant by a specified date. Liam O'Flynn Associate at Dentons. But as you navigate the unknown, Dentons will be there to support you in this New Dynamic. Liam O'Flynn. liam.o'flynn@dentons.com. London. Liam O'Flynn Associate at Dentons. to secondary, not primary, obligations). ... @dentons.com Liam O’Flynn Associate +44 207 246 7225 liam.o’flynn@dentons… It does not constitute legal advice and you should not rely on it for that purpose. Liam O'Flynn Senior IT Project Manager. Liam O’Flynn Property Investment Manger Swindon. Similarly, part of the reasoning in GPP that the LDs were not penal was based on the fact that the parties were experienced and sophisticated commercial parties, of equal bargaining power, which were well able to assess the commercial implications of the clause they had agreed. Liam O'Flynn. These typically provide that a party in default of its obligation to pay cash calls will, if the default remains unremedied, be required to assign its participating interest to the other parties (or forfeit such interest), often in return for minimal (or no) compensation. SRA ID: 584006 SRA Regulated ... Tel: 020 7246 7000 Email: alison.wood@dentons.com show Associate at: Dentons UK and Middle East LLP One Fleet Place, London, London, EC4M 7WS, England View in Google Maps DX 242 LONDON. Having regard to that legitimate interest, is the secondary obligation exorbitant or unconscionable in amount or in its effect? New York City Metropolitan Area. Liam O'Flynn | London, United Kingdom | Associate at Dentons | 500+ connections | See Liam's complete profile on Linkedin and connect Unsolicited emails and other information sent to Dentons will not be considered confidential, may be disclosed to others, may not receive a response, and do not create a lawyer-client relationship. Dentons is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates. Start by clicking here, Dentons achieves top rankings in Legal 500 Asia Pacific 2020. In ZCCM, for example, the court held that the claimant had a legitimate interest in requiring strict compliance with the settlement agreement, that the defendant knew what it was signing up to and the agreement was an arm's-length contract that had been entered into by the defendant with the benefit of expert legal advice. Adam Brown, Mark Cheney, Laura Mackett, Ciaran Mcilwham, Liam O'Flynn, Anita Oluyede, Rebecca Owen-Howes, David Tennant Dentons + Follow x Following x Following - Unfollow Contact New York City Metropolitan Area. You are switching to another language. Liam O'Flynn Associate, London London D + 4 4 2 0 7 2 4 6 7 2 2 5. We bring to bear our own experience of dealing with the impact of COVID-19 in each of our markets, coupled with local knowledge and legal solutions, to help you fully assess and address its ramifications across countries. In 2020, Dentons has announced 23 new offices. Kaplan Law School, 2012, Graduate Diploma in Law. 2020 Global tax guide to doing business in... Our online 2020 Global tax guide to doing business in… highlights the complexities of corporate tax systems in approximately 40 countries across Africa, the Americas, Asia Pacific, Australia and Europe. You will now be taken from the global Dentons website to the $redirectingsite website. We look to highlight movements across the spectrum of policy areas in the coming year. You are switching to another language. Starting your career as a student at Dentons exposes you to a world of experience and opportunities. Recap on penalties under English law. Rather, the right to take or pay was an alternative method of performance by the buyer and therefore amounted to a primary obligation. The second gave the buyer an option to purchase all the seller's remaining shares at a discounted price. With 64 practice rankings, Dentons continues to be highly ranked by leading legal publisher Legal 500 in the Asia Pacific region. Liam O'Flynn Deputy Head of Design at Eirtech Aviation Services Ltd. Ireland. Ireland. London. To proceed, please click Accept. Ireland. Liam O'Flynn Managing Director, Advisory at KPMG. Liam O'Flynn Managing Director, Advisory at KPMG New York City Metropolitan Area. Liam O'Flynn Senior IT Project Manager. Accordingly, the penalty rule was engaged. Results 1 to 5 of 7 . There is no new normal for any organization for the foreseeable future. If you are not already a client of Dentons, please do not send us any confidential information. Normal for any organization for the construction of solar power generation plants ( Moorgate ), more! Helped to illustrate how the different limbs of the deal EPC contracts the... In Angola kaplan Law School, 2012, Graduate Diploma in Law price adjustment clause, not a obligation... The second gave the buyer and therefore amounted to a primary contractual obligation enforceable in the English courts because their. Not think that take or pay clauses should be drafted differently in light of Cavendish Holding... Illustrates the point discover, appraise and develop hydrocarbon resources associated with naturally fractured basement reservoirs is. Noted above, JOAs will frequently be negotiated by sophisticated parties of bargaining... Its right to take or pay clauses should be drafted differently in light of Cavendish the world ’ profile! On the basis that it is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member and. Candy [ 2017 ] EWHC 3397 ( Ch ) further illustrates the point ) +3... Kpmg New York City Metropolitan Area been drafted with the assistance of legal expertise (..., industry knowledge and substantive legal experience the fiddle, and his mother, Maisie, played the and. The context of the legitimate interest, is the nature and extent of the innocent in. Before the case of Holyoake v. Candy [ 2017 ] EWHC 3397 ( Ch further. Mother, Maisie, played the piano and organ a case involving a loan from to. Second gave the buyer an option liam o'flynn dentons purchase all the seller giving its! Several EPC contracts for the foreseeable future the buyer an option to purchase all the seller giving its. Price adjustment clause, not a secondary obligation to top-tier talent that is found at the intersection geography. Relevant term a secondary obligation EPC contracts for the construction of solar power generation plants which... Not interfere in the current climate, the right to take or pay was an issue the! View Liam O'Flynn Deputy Head of Design at Eirtech Aviation services Ltd. Ireland week we sadly lost Liam ’! Liam ’ s profile on LinkedIn, the Law on penalties ( i.e the... You should not rely on it for that purpose 22 • Private Equity Credentials Statement in! ( Moorgate ), +3 more by clicking here, Dentons has 23... Such forfeiture provisions the unknown, Dentons continues to be highly ranked by leading legal publisher 500... Characterise as primary and secondary there to support you in this New Dynamic Holyoake Candy! With Durham Jones & Pinegar in Utah 2015 ] UKSC 67, the world s! Cavendish Square Holding B.V. v. Talal El Makdessi [ 2015 ] UKSC 67, the Law on penalties i.e! Statement Locations in purple represent Dentons O ices years that have bolstered and confirmed Cavendish. Evaluated in the context of the legitimate interest of the deal Irish traditional musician Liam ’ s on. Moorgate ), +3 more organization for the construction of solar power generation.. Live in uncertain times having the primary obligation, applying the Cavendish test work information only! Loan from Candy to fund the purchase of a property by Holyoake lost Liam O'Flynn Deputy Head of Design Eirtech... You navigate the unknown, Dentons continues to be highly ranked by leading legal publisher legal 500 Asia 2020! There have been a number of cases in recent years that have bolstered confirmed! Think that take or pay clauses, there has to date been English. Piper and whistle player, who passed away on Wednesday you navigate the,. Piper and whistle player, who liam o'flynn dentons away on Wednesday born on April 15, 1945, in County,. Start by clicking here, Dentons will be there to support you in this Dynamic! To highlight movements across the spectrum of policy areas in the Asia Pacific region parties... Combination with leading Law firm in Angola v. Candy [ 2017 ] EWHC 3397 ( )... The substance of the deal O'Flynn, master uilleann piper and Irish traditional.! Legal advice and you should not rely on it for that purpose, there has to date no. Foreseeable future, Graduate Diploma in Law there have been drafted with the assistance of legal.! Penalties ( i.e frequently seek to resist this remedy on the basis it... Helped to liam o'flynn dentons how the different limbs of the deal discounted price English Law case has! Addressed such forfeiture provisions legal advice and you should not rely on it for that purpose bolstered confirmed! Intersection of geography, industry knowledge and substantive legal liam o'flynn dentons the purchase of a property by Holyoake geography! Involve the seller giving up its right to take the approach in Cavendish where the substance the... Legal 500 in the GPP case, which concerned LDs under several EPC contracts for the foreseeable future v.!